In which the writer discovers why it’s a bit of a waste of time to try to accompany a baroque opera with a modern orchestra.
You’d be hard pressed to find anyone in New Zealand who is more delighted that Germany’s Lautten Compagney will be playing here for the Xerxes season than James Tibbles. As the Head of Early Music Studies at the University of Auckland, he’s as passionate about this musical era as it’s possible to be. We’re not saying that he has Bach or Handel as his cellphone ringtone (although he probably does), but the wizards of the Middle Ages, the Renaissance and the baroque periods are what get him up in the morning.
So, it’s quite good news, then? “Definitely,” he says. “The Lautten Compagney has an outstanding reputation in Europe for their playing style and their commitment to baroque performance, and they play across a vast repertoire from the 16th to the 18th century.
These specialist players will be bringing to this opera something that New Zealand audiences have never heard here before. What I think is really exciting and insightful is that a mainstream opera company that doesn’t specialise in baroque works has decided to put on a baroque opera, using baroque instrumentalists and singers who are experienced in this style.”
But is it really important to use baroque players? Couldn’t the Auckland Philharmonia Orchestra and the Vector Wellington Orchestra do the same job? “There are lots of differences in approach to the repertoire that happen as soon as you draw a group of baroque string players together, as opposed to those who are modern players. Their insights into the period – in this case the 18th century – result in performances that are almost automatically vibrant, exciting and cutting-edge. The audience hears something that is fresh, not just because it’s different from the modern orchestral techniques, but also because an historically informed approach is all about looking behind the notes on the page and finding the rhetoric, the persuasive style of performance, which is what this music is about.”
It’s more than just style and having the right baroque kind of attitude, though surely. What about the physical nuts-and-bolts differences in the instruments?
If you put a baroque violin and a modern violin side by side, at first glance they are exactly the same instrument, James tells me. The Stradivarius instruments played by famous concert violinists today are a very long way away from their original set-up. The original instruments were strung in gut and had a lower bridge than modern violins. The angle of the neck was also different. “This gives a sound that is sweeter than a standard modern violin,” James continues. “It’s not as loud so the sound is drawn out of the instrument, rather than being pushed to the back of a large concert hall.”
Pitch, too, has changed down the centuries. The standard pitch of the modern orchestra is very different to that of baroque times, which varied all through Europe. The baroque standard is now around about a semitone below modern pitch. “Even more interesting than that,” James adds, “is that the tuning of the instruments is fundamentally different from the modern equal temperament and the way the instruments are tuned with unequal semitones gives the music a very special character where each key has its own personality. That’s a very special feature that will be brought to these performances.
“But the most interesting and special characteristic is that with the shape and articulation qualities of the baroque bow, the music speaks very clearly and articulately. The bows go very, very quickly. The music can go lightning fast, compared with the more heavy and even bow strokes of the modern bow and bowing styles. And the same applies to the baroque cello and violone. The violone, being a fretted instrument, has a much more focused sound than the modern double bass and obviously a lute is nothing like anything else. It acts a little bit like a guitar because it’s plucked but the resonant qualities of the lute are unique and the instruments we will be seeing and hearing will be a lot larger than a guitar. When we look at the earlier repertoire – for example the operas of Monteverdi, Cavalli and Cavalieri – the music just tends to sound ridiculous and of no particular interest without these specific instrumental colours. Most people recognise that 17th-century music just isn’t okay on modern instruments. Getting the real thing with the very clear and beautiful and articulate sound of the baroque instruments is something that New Zealand audiences will absolutely adore.”
So, that’s part of the reason that baroque operas ceased being performed in the 19th century? It wasn’t that there was anything wrong with the music – it just didn’t sound all that great with continuous vibrato and the other trappings of 20th-century performances.
Just when I think I’ve got the whole baroquemodern thing sorted, James throws in another musical curve ball. Not all baroque ensembles are the same, which I suppose is obvious when you think about it. It all depends, he tells me, on where they come from.
“If we were to put a group of baroque ensembles from different countries together on a stage, it would be easy to hear that English-trained baroque musicians make a completely different sound from those who come from a school of playing influenced by the Dutch performers – and the German approach is different again. It is wonderful to have the possibility of experiencing a German company of very fine baroque specialists in this country. Most of the baroque musicians working at a professional level in New Zealand have studied in the Netherlands, so our own baroque ensembles have an approach that is very much based on the Dutch school.
And, finally, size does matter. We are used to seeing a modern-day opera orchestra with anything from 40 to 90 players in the pit, “so when the baroque musicians walk on stage, you’re surprised at how relatively tiny the ensemble is”, James says. (The Lautten Compagney is bringing 20 musicians.) “But the word ‘orchestra’ is quite problematic as a lot of the 18th-century repertoire is really conceived for a small number of violins, as opposed to the modern orchestral set-up, with several desks of violins on each part. This gives the baroque ensembles a tremendous agility and flexibility. Each individual player is largely autonomous, rather than relying on ensemble skills and matching the ‘leader’. It makes the baroque repertoire more like glorified chamber music.”
Diana Balham
Publications Editor